Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees? The Next CEO of Stack OverflowAnonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch

pgfplots: How to draw a tangent graph below two others?

Is there a rule of thumb for determining the amount one should accept for of a settlement offer?

How exploitable/balanced is this homebrew spell: Spell Permanency?

Are British MPs missing the point, with these 'Indicative Votes'?

What does this strange code stamp on my passport mean?

Why does freezing point matter when picking cooler ice packs?

Is it OK to decorate a log book cover?

Creating a script with console commands

How can a day be of 24 hours?

The sum of any ten consecutive numbers from a fibonacci sequence is divisible by 11

Ising model simulation

Cannot restore registry to default in Windows 10?

Avoiding the "not like other girls" trope?

Compensation for working overtime on Saturdays

Man transported from Alternate World into ours by a Neutrino Detector

Why did the Drakh emissary look so blurred in S04:E11 "Lines of Communication"?

Another proof that dividing by 0 does not exist -- is it right?

Can you teleport closer to a creature you are Frightened of?

Is it possible to make a 9x9 table fit within the default margins?

How do I keep Mac Emacs from trapping M-`?

Planeswalker Ability and Death Timing

How do I secure a TV wall mount?

Masking layers by a vector polygon layer in QGIS

Find the majority element, which appears more than half the time



Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees?



The Next CEO of Stack OverflowAnonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch










3















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question



















  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago















3















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question



















  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago













3












3








3








Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question
















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur




halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 3 hours ago







רבות מחשבות

















asked 3 hours ago









רבות מחשבותרבות מחשבות

14.6k129122




14.6k129122







  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago












  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago







1




1





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago




2




2





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
3 hours ago





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
3 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















2














R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer






























    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes








    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    2














    R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



    Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




    גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



    There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







    share|improve this answer



























      2














      R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



      Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




      גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



      There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







      share|improve this answer

























        2












        2








        2







        R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



        Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




        גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



        There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







        share|improve this answer













        R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



        Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




        גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



        There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.








        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 3 hours ago









        AlexAlex

        22.9k156130




        22.9k156130













            -

            Popular posts from this blog

            Era Viking Índice Início da Era Viquingue | Cotidiano | Sociedade | Língua | Religião | A arte | As primeiras cidades | As viagens dos viquingues | Viquingues do Oeste e Leste | Fim da Era Viquingue | Fontes históricas | Referências Bibliografia | Ligações externas | Menu de navegação«Sverige då!»«Handel I vikingetid»«O que é Nórdico Antigo»Mito, magia e religião na volsunga saga Um olhar sobre a trajetória mítica do herói sigurd«Bonden var den verklige vikingen»«Vikingatiden»«Vikingatiden»«Vinland»«Guerreiras de Óðinn: As Valkyrjor na Mitologia Viking»1519-9053«Esculpindo símbolos e seres: A arte viking em pedras rúnicas»1679-9313Historia - Tema: VikingarnaAventura e Magia no Mundo das Sagas IslandesasEra Vikinge

            Image
            Era Viking suecodinamarquêsnorueguêsislandêsEscandináviavikingsPaíses Nórdicospré-históriaIdade do FerroIdade MédiaEscandinávianavios viquinguesthrallamantes legítimasagriculturacomérciocomerciantesartesãosHeidibaRibeSigtunapadrescristianizaçãopedras rúnicasnórdico antigocaracteres rúnicoscristianismoassesOdimTorFreirCristoAnsgárioLuís Ipedras rúnicasgravuras rupestresRibeJutlândiaHedebyAlemanhaDinamarcaKaupangNoruegaUppåkraEscâniaBircaVale do MalarSigtunaEscaraVísbianórdicosEscandináviaEuropaÁsiaÁfricaAméricaDinamarcaSuéciadanosFrançaIlhas BritânicasNoruegaIslândiaGroenlândiaAmérica do NorteSuelândiasuíonesGotlândiagotasPaíses BálticosRússiamar NegroMar CáspioImpério BizantinoCalifado AbássidaNovogárdiaQuieveAnatóliavareguesMediterrâneoCruzadasGotl...
            Read more

            Metrô de Los Teques Índice Linhas | Estações | Ver também | Referências Ligações externas | Menu de navegação«INSTITUCIÓN»«Mapa de rutas»originalMetrô de Los TequesC.A. Metro Los Teques |Alcaldía de Guaicaipuro – Sitio OficialGobernacion de Mirandaeeeeeee

            Image
            Metrô de Los TequesFundações na Venezuela em 2006 metropolitanoLos TequesGuaicaipuroMirandaGoverno da VenezuelaLinha 1Linha 2estaçõesLinha 1Linha 2IndependenciaSan AntonioLinha 3GuaicaipuroLibertadorEstação Las AdjuntasMetrô de Caracasalgarismocorestaçõesnomecorestaçõesestações Metrô de Los Teques Uma das composições que operam no sistema. Informações Proprietário Governo da Venezuela Local [[ Los Teques, Miranda]] País variant = Tipo de transporte Metropolitano Número de linhas 2 Número de estações 5 Website [1] Funcionamento Início de funcionamento 3 de novembro de 2006 (12 anos) [ 1 ] Operadora(s) C. A. Metro Los Teques Dados técnicos Extensão do sistema 11,2 km Bitola Bitola padrão (1435 mm) Velocidade máxima 80 km/h ...
            Read more

            What's the metal clinking sound at the end of credits in Avengers: Endgame?What makes Thanos so strong in Avengers: Endgame?Who is the character that appears at the end of Endgame?What happens to Mjolnir (Thor's hammer) at the end of Endgame?The People's Ages in Avengers: EndgameWhat did Nebula do in Avengers: Endgame?Messing with time in the Avengers: Endgame climaxAvengers: Endgame timelineWhat are the time-travel rules in Avengers Endgame?Why use this song in Avengers: Endgame Opening Logo Sequence?Peggy's age in Avengers Endgame

            Image
            How could Tony Stark make this in Endgame? What's the metal clinking sound at the end of credits in Avengers: Endgame? Short story about a planet with two sentient species How can Republicans who favour free markets, consistently express anger when they don't like the outcome of that choice? How do we know that ממחרת השבת means from the first day of pesach and not the seventh? How to creep the reader out with what seems like a normal person? How to back up a running remote server? What does YCWCYODFTRFDTY mean? Rivers without rain How to make a pipeline wait for end-of-file or stop after an error? Is this a realistic set of world maps? Can fracking help reduce CO2? function to receive a character input and return date format (with incorrect input) Counterexample: a pair of linearly ordered sets that are isomorphic to subsets of the other, but not isomorphic between them Why do Computer Science majors learn...
            Read more