PTIJ: Who should pay for Uber rides: the child or the parent?Parashat Vayikra + ZachorPurim and Shushan PurimPTIJ: For whom should I vote? (US Presidential Elections 2016)Can Trump Make Mexico Pay for the Wall?PTIJ: Who are the Assistant kings?PTIJ - Who is Boris KarshinaPTIJ: I know who Solomon the Wise is but who is Solomon the Good?PTIJ: Aliyot for the deceasedPTiJ: How should animals pray?PTIJ: Who was the sixth set of priestly clothes for?PTIJ: Who is the most praiseworthy?PTIJ: Selling a Get

It's a yearly task, alright

How could a scammer know the apps on my phone / iTunes account?

Russian cases: A few examples, I'm really confused

Be in awe of my brilliance!

Running a subshell from the middle of the current command

Can unconscious characters be unwilling?

Could the Saturn V actually have launched astronauts around Venus?

What is Thermal Runaway Protection?

Rules about breaking the rules. How do I do it well?

Can the damage from a Talisman of Pure Good (or Ultimate Evil) be non-lethal?

Citation at the bottom for subfigures in beamer frame

Co-worker team leader wants to inject his friend's awful software into our development. What should I say to our common boss?

Product of trinomials which is still of the same form

Why would a flight no longer considered airworthy be redirected like this?

An Accountant Seeks the Help of a Mathematician

Rejected in 4th interview round citing insufficient years of experience

Instead of Universal Basic Income, why not Universal Basic NEEDS?

Is having access to past exams cheating and, if yes, could it be proven just by a good grade?

How to answer questions about my characters?

My adviser wants to be the first author

What has been your most complicated TikZ drawing?

Ban on all campaign finance?

/bin/ls output does not match manpage

What is IP squat space



PTIJ: Who should pay for Uber rides: the child or the parent?



Parashat Vayikra + Zachor
Purim and Shushan PurimPTIJ: For whom should I vote? (US Presidential Elections 2016)Can Trump Make Mexico Pay for the Wall?PTIJ: Who are the Assistant kings?PTIJ - Who is Boris KarshinaPTIJ: I know who Solomon the Wise is but who is Solomon the Good?PTIJ: Aliyot for the deceasedPTiJ: How should animals pray?PTIJ: Who was the sixth set of priestly clothes for?PTIJ: Who is the most praiseworthy?PTIJ: Selling a Get










2















There's a big machlokes in shas about ridesharing. Namely, who pays for it: the mother (parent) or the child?




"עובר ירך אמו" vs "עובר לאו ירך אמו"



"Uber should be charged to the parent" vs "Uber should NOT be charged to the parent"




Thoughts on how we might pasken?

Would the halacha be similar or different for Lyft?










share|improve this question

















  • 2





    My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

    – DanF
    2 hours ago






  • 1





    @DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

    – alicht
    2 hours ago















2















There's a big machlokes in shas about ridesharing. Namely, who pays for it: the mother (parent) or the child?




"עובר ירך אמו" vs "עובר לאו ירך אמו"



"Uber should be charged to the parent" vs "Uber should NOT be charged to the parent"




Thoughts on how we might pasken?

Would the halacha be similar or different for Lyft?










share|improve this question

















  • 2





    My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

    – DanF
    2 hours ago






  • 1





    @DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

    – alicht
    2 hours ago













2












2








2








There's a big machlokes in shas about ridesharing. Namely, who pays for it: the mother (parent) or the child?




"עובר ירך אמו" vs "עובר לאו ירך אמו"



"Uber should be charged to the parent" vs "Uber should NOT be charged to the parent"




Thoughts on how we might pasken?

Would the halacha be similar or different for Lyft?










share|improve this question














There's a big machlokes in shas about ridesharing. Namely, who pays for it: the mother (parent) or the child?




"עובר ירך אמו" vs "עובר לאו ירך אמו"



"Uber should be charged to the parent" vs "Uber should NOT be charged to the parent"




Thoughts on how we might pasken?

Would the halacha be similar or different for Lyft?







purim-torah-in-jest






share|improve this question













share|improve this question











share|improve this question




share|improve this question










asked 4 hours ago









alichtalicht

2,0021428




2,0021428







  • 2





    My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

    – DanF
    2 hours ago






  • 1





    @DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

    – alicht
    2 hours ago












  • 2





    My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

    – DanF
    2 hours ago






  • 1





    @DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

    – alicht
    2 hours ago







2




2





My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

– DanF
2 hours ago





My Hebrew is lacking, here. The word ירך means "charged to"??

– DanF
2 hours ago




1




1





@DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

– alicht
2 hours ago





@DanF it does not- literally means "thigh" 😬#sorryaboutthat

– alicht
2 hours ago










3 Answers
3






active

oldest

votes


















3














I believe that the one who pays is the one who does the action of making the arrangements, as we hold עובר לעשייתן, that the Uber goes to the one who does the work for it.






share|improve this answer























  • So...the driver?

    – DonielF
    2 hours ago











  • @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

    – alicht
    2 hours ago


















2














While rosends's answer covers Uber, what about Lyft? Berachos 40a says:




אמר רב חסדא קיתון לפת



Rav Chisda said, a kid on the Lyft.




What does this mean? Does this mean that the kid pays for it, or that the parent pays for the Lyft on top of the kid? On 43a, the Gemara elaborates:




הסבה לפת מהניא



The grandfather [for the] Lyft helps.




This clearly implies that the elder generation pays for it, and so the parent pays for the child.






share|improve this answer






























    1














    This question is asked as long ago as the Gemara:
    (Sanhedrin 57b):




    משום רבי ישמעאל אמרו אף על העוברין מאי טעמיה דרבי ישמעאל דכתיב (בראשית ט, ו) שופך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך איזהו אדם שהוא באדם הוי אומר זה עובר שבמעי אמו- it was said in the name of rabbi yishmael: why even the Uber users? As it says, ‘the one who pours money of man, his own money will be poured in man’. Who is this ‘man whose will be poured in man’? That who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach”
    We see from here, that one who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach, I.e. the son, he ends up pouring his money into man (gives his money to the cabby) [דם in this instance means money, like דמים, not blood]




    The achronim talk about this as well:
    (shita mekubetzes Bava Basra 139b)




    עובר בן הוא לא עדיף- Uber, a son is not preferred
    We see then, that the shita mekubetzes argues with the Gemara! The chachmas Adam solves this contradiction:
    (chachmas adam 28)



    עובר בן ח' או בן ט'- Uber, [only] an 8 or 9 year old son
    Only from 8 or 9 years old does a son need to pay for his parents Uber.




    The Gemara is talking about a child under the age of 8, who is not expected to finance his parents Uber. The shita mekubetzes is talking about an older child, from 8/9 and up, who is expected to finance his parents Uber.
    This is how we pasken (as there are no other sources that talk about it).
    As for Lyft, it says in herchev davar al Bereshit (27):




    מצות כיבוד אב כמו שאירע ליפת. - it is a mitzva of kibbud av va’em like what happened with Lyft.




    We see from here that we learn Hilchos kibbud av va’em for Uber from Lyft! So for sure the Halachos will be the same!






    share|improve this answer






























      3 Answers
      3






      active

      oldest

      votes








      3 Answers
      3






      active

      oldest

      votes









      active

      oldest

      votes






      active

      oldest

      votes









      3














      I believe that the one who pays is the one who does the action of making the arrangements, as we hold עובר לעשייתן, that the Uber goes to the one who does the work for it.






      share|improve this answer























      • So...the driver?

        – DonielF
        2 hours ago











      • @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

        – alicht
        2 hours ago















      3














      I believe that the one who pays is the one who does the action of making the arrangements, as we hold עובר לעשייתן, that the Uber goes to the one who does the work for it.






      share|improve this answer























      • So...the driver?

        – DonielF
        2 hours ago











      • @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

        – alicht
        2 hours ago













      3












      3








      3







      I believe that the one who pays is the one who does the action of making the arrangements, as we hold עובר לעשייתן, that the Uber goes to the one who does the work for it.






      share|improve this answer













      I believe that the one who pays is the one who does the action of making the arrangements, as we hold עובר לעשייתן, that the Uber goes to the one who does the work for it.







      share|improve this answer












      share|improve this answer



      share|improve this answer










      answered 3 hours ago









      rosendsrosends

      21k32672




      21k32672












      • So...the driver?

        – DonielF
        2 hours ago











      • @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

        – alicht
        2 hours ago

















      • So...the driver?

        – DonielF
        2 hours ago











      • @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

        – alicht
        2 hours ago
















      So...the driver?

      – DonielF
      2 hours ago





      So...the driver?

      – DonielF
      2 hours ago













      @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

      – alicht
      2 hours ago





      @rosends gevaldik- shkoyach!

      – alicht
      2 hours ago











      2














      While rosends's answer covers Uber, what about Lyft? Berachos 40a says:




      אמר רב חסדא קיתון לפת



      Rav Chisda said, a kid on the Lyft.




      What does this mean? Does this mean that the kid pays for it, or that the parent pays for the Lyft on top of the kid? On 43a, the Gemara elaborates:




      הסבה לפת מהניא



      The grandfather [for the] Lyft helps.




      This clearly implies that the elder generation pays for it, and so the parent pays for the child.






      share|improve this answer



























        2














        While rosends's answer covers Uber, what about Lyft? Berachos 40a says:




        אמר רב חסדא קיתון לפת



        Rav Chisda said, a kid on the Lyft.




        What does this mean? Does this mean that the kid pays for it, or that the parent pays for the Lyft on top of the kid? On 43a, the Gemara elaborates:




        הסבה לפת מהניא



        The grandfather [for the] Lyft helps.




        This clearly implies that the elder generation pays for it, and so the parent pays for the child.






        share|improve this answer

























          2












          2








          2







          While rosends's answer covers Uber, what about Lyft? Berachos 40a says:




          אמר רב חסדא קיתון לפת



          Rav Chisda said, a kid on the Lyft.




          What does this mean? Does this mean that the kid pays for it, or that the parent pays for the Lyft on top of the kid? On 43a, the Gemara elaborates:




          הסבה לפת מהניא



          The grandfather [for the] Lyft helps.




          This clearly implies that the elder generation pays for it, and so the parent pays for the child.






          share|improve this answer













          While rosends's answer covers Uber, what about Lyft? Berachos 40a says:




          אמר רב חסדא קיתון לפת



          Rav Chisda said, a kid on the Lyft.




          What does this mean? Does this mean that the kid pays for it, or that the parent pays for the Lyft on top of the kid? On 43a, the Gemara elaborates:




          הסבה לפת מהניא



          The grandfather [for the] Lyft helps.




          This clearly implies that the elder generation pays for it, and so the parent pays for the child.







          share|improve this answer












          share|improve this answer



          share|improve this answer










          answered 2 hours ago









          DonielFDonielF

          15.4k12482




          15.4k12482





















              1














              This question is asked as long ago as the Gemara:
              (Sanhedrin 57b):




              משום רבי ישמעאל אמרו אף על העוברין מאי טעמיה דרבי ישמעאל דכתיב (בראשית ט, ו) שופך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך איזהו אדם שהוא באדם הוי אומר זה עובר שבמעי אמו- it was said in the name of rabbi yishmael: why even the Uber users? As it says, ‘the one who pours money of man, his own money will be poured in man’. Who is this ‘man whose will be poured in man’? That who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach”
              We see from here, that one who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach, I.e. the son, he ends up pouring his money into man (gives his money to the cabby) [דם in this instance means money, like דמים, not blood]




              The achronim talk about this as well:
              (shita mekubetzes Bava Basra 139b)




              עובר בן הוא לא עדיף- Uber, a son is not preferred
              We see then, that the shita mekubetzes argues with the Gemara! The chachmas Adam solves this contradiction:
              (chachmas adam 28)



              עובר בן ח' או בן ט'- Uber, [only] an 8 or 9 year old son
              Only from 8 or 9 years old does a son need to pay for his parents Uber.




              The Gemara is talking about a child under the age of 8, who is not expected to finance his parents Uber. The shita mekubetzes is talking about an older child, from 8/9 and up, who is expected to finance his parents Uber.
              This is how we pasken (as there are no other sources that talk about it).
              As for Lyft, it says in herchev davar al Bereshit (27):




              מצות כיבוד אב כמו שאירע ליפת. - it is a mitzva of kibbud av va’em like what happened with Lyft.




              We see from here that we learn Hilchos kibbud av va’em for Uber from Lyft! So for sure the Halachos will be the same!






              share|improve this answer



























                1














                This question is asked as long ago as the Gemara:
                (Sanhedrin 57b):




                משום רבי ישמעאל אמרו אף על העוברין מאי טעמיה דרבי ישמעאל דכתיב (בראשית ט, ו) שופך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך איזהו אדם שהוא באדם הוי אומר זה עובר שבמעי אמו- it was said in the name of rabbi yishmael: why even the Uber users? As it says, ‘the one who pours money of man, his own money will be poured in man’. Who is this ‘man whose will be poured in man’? That who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach”
                We see from here, that one who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach, I.e. the son, he ends up pouring his money into man (gives his money to the cabby) [דם in this instance means money, like דמים, not blood]




                The achronim talk about this as well:
                (shita mekubetzes Bava Basra 139b)




                עובר בן הוא לא עדיף- Uber, a son is not preferred
                We see then, that the shita mekubetzes argues with the Gemara! The chachmas Adam solves this contradiction:
                (chachmas adam 28)



                עובר בן ח' או בן ט'- Uber, [only] an 8 or 9 year old son
                Only from 8 or 9 years old does a son need to pay for his parents Uber.




                The Gemara is talking about a child under the age of 8, who is not expected to finance his parents Uber. The shita mekubetzes is talking about an older child, from 8/9 and up, who is expected to finance his parents Uber.
                This is how we pasken (as there are no other sources that talk about it).
                As for Lyft, it says in herchev davar al Bereshit (27):




                מצות כיבוד אב כמו שאירע ליפת. - it is a mitzva of kibbud av va’em like what happened with Lyft.




                We see from here that we learn Hilchos kibbud av va’em for Uber from Lyft! So for sure the Halachos will be the same!






                share|improve this answer

























                  1












                  1








                  1







                  This question is asked as long ago as the Gemara:
                  (Sanhedrin 57b):




                  משום רבי ישמעאל אמרו אף על העוברין מאי טעמיה דרבי ישמעאל דכתיב (בראשית ט, ו) שופך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך איזהו אדם שהוא באדם הוי אומר זה עובר שבמעי אמו- it was said in the name of rabbi yishmael: why even the Uber users? As it says, ‘the one who pours money of man, his own money will be poured in man’. Who is this ‘man whose will be poured in man’? That who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach”
                  We see from here, that one who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach, I.e. the son, he ends up pouring his money into man (gives his money to the cabby) [דם in this instance means money, like דמים, not blood]




                  The achronim talk about this as well:
                  (shita mekubetzes Bava Basra 139b)




                  עובר בן הוא לא עדיף- Uber, a son is not preferred
                  We see then, that the shita mekubetzes argues with the Gemara! The chachmas Adam solves this contradiction:
                  (chachmas adam 28)



                  עובר בן ח' או בן ט'- Uber, [only] an 8 or 9 year old son
                  Only from 8 or 9 years old does a son need to pay for his parents Uber.




                  The Gemara is talking about a child under the age of 8, who is not expected to finance his parents Uber. The shita mekubetzes is talking about an older child, from 8/9 and up, who is expected to finance his parents Uber.
                  This is how we pasken (as there are no other sources that talk about it).
                  As for Lyft, it says in herchev davar al Bereshit (27):




                  מצות כיבוד אב כמו שאירע ליפת. - it is a mitzva of kibbud av va’em like what happened with Lyft.




                  We see from here that we learn Hilchos kibbud av va’em for Uber from Lyft! So for sure the Halachos will be the same!






                  share|improve this answer













                  This question is asked as long ago as the Gemara:
                  (Sanhedrin 57b):




                  משום רבי ישמעאל אמרו אף על העוברין מאי טעמיה דרבי ישמעאל דכתיב (בראשית ט, ו) שופך דם האדם באדם דמו ישפך איזהו אדם שהוא באדם הוי אומר זה עובר שבמעי אמו- it was said in the name of rabbi yishmael: why even the Uber users? As it says, ‘the one who pours money of man, his own money will be poured in man’. Who is this ‘man whose will be poured in man’? That who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach”
                  We see from here, that one who Uber’s in his mother’s stomach, I.e. the son, he ends up pouring his money into man (gives his money to the cabby) [דם in this instance means money, like דמים, not blood]




                  The achronim talk about this as well:
                  (shita mekubetzes Bava Basra 139b)




                  עובר בן הוא לא עדיף- Uber, a son is not preferred
                  We see then, that the shita mekubetzes argues with the Gemara! The chachmas Adam solves this contradiction:
                  (chachmas adam 28)



                  עובר בן ח' או בן ט'- Uber, [only] an 8 or 9 year old son
                  Only from 8 or 9 years old does a son need to pay for his parents Uber.




                  The Gemara is talking about a child under the age of 8, who is not expected to finance his parents Uber. The shita mekubetzes is talking about an older child, from 8/9 and up, who is expected to finance his parents Uber.
                  This is how we pasken (as there are no other sources that talk about it).
                  As for Lyft, it says in herchev davar al Bereshit (27):




                  מצות כיבוד אב כמו שאירע ליפת. - it is a mitzva of kibbud av va’em like what happened with Lyft.




                  We see from here that we learn Hilchos kibbud av va’em for Uber from Lyft! So for sure the Halachos will be the same!







                  share|improve this answer












                  share|improve this answer



                  share|improve this answer










                  answered 2 hours ago









                  Lo aniLo ani

                  48213




                  48213













                      Popular posts from this blog

                      Which organization defines CJK Unified Ideographs? The Next CEO of Stack OverflowCharacters which have several different shapesHow useful are the kanji in reading Chinese?Can Chinese readers scan large amounts of text faster/more accurately than their alphabet-using counterparts?丼: why is “well” also “bowl of food”?What Does Unicode 8.0 Mean For Chinese?How are blanks indicated for placeholders in Chinese (like ???)Is there a dictionary of standard character variants?How to display CJK Extension F?How is it decided as to which character is used on the tech terminology?How does 子 come to mean 'midnight'?

                      Shenzhen Football Club Índice Elenco atual | Títulos | Referências Ligações externas | Menu de navegaçãoGooglenotíciaslivrosacadêmicoeditar«"Elenco"»Site oficialexpandindo-oeee

                      When We Were Young (canção de Adele) Índice Antecedentes e lançamento | Faixas e formatos | Performances e covers | Desempenho nas tabelas musicais | Créditos | Histórico de lançamento | Referências Menu de navegação«Best albums of 2015»«Adele - When We Were Young (Radio Date: 22-01-2016)»«When We Were Young - Single by Adele»«Adele: Inside Her Private Life and Triumphant Return»«adele interview: world exclusive first interview in three years»«Tobias Jesso Jr: since Adele tweeted his song, he's even bigger than his dad»«Adele interviews Tobias Jesso Jr: 'I think that a couple of the ideas we had could be rap songs'»«Adele on Her Return: 'I Was So Frightened That No One Cared'»«Tobias Jesso Jr. on working with Adele: 'I was as nervous as shit'»«How Ariel Rechtshaid Pushed Adele To Her Limit»«Adele Previews 'When We Were Young' on '60 Minutes' Teaser, Tops Trending 140»«Adele Performs New '25' Ballad, "When We Were Young" Live: Watch»«Which '25' Song Should Be Adele's Next Single?»«Adele's 'When We Were Young' Confirmed As Second Single From '25'»«Adele's new single artwork for 'When We Were Young' is perfectly adorable»«Adele at the BBC review: honest, funny and spectacular – Celebrity News News»«'Saturday Night Live': Adele Sings 'Hello' and 'When We Were Young'»«'Adele: Live in New York City' NBC Special – Set List Revealed!»«Adele Closes Out the 2016 Brit Awards With 'When We Were Young'»«What Is The Adele Live Tour Set List? There's No Way She'd Leave Out These 8 Songs»«See Demi Lovato's Soaring Cover of Adele's 'When We Were Young'»«'The Voice': 5 Best Moments From Week 1 Blind Auditions»«Adele – When We Were Young (Media Control Charts)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Entertainment Monitoring Africa)»«Adele – When We Were Young (ARIA Charts)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Ö3 Austria Top 40)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Ultratop 50)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Ultratop 40)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Canadian Hot 100)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Tracklisten)»«Adele – When We Were Young (The Official Charts Company)»«Adele – Hello (IFPI Slovenská Republika)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Productores de Música de España)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Billboard Hot 100)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Pop Songs)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Adult Pop Songs)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Hot Adult Contemporary Charts)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Hot Dance Club Songs)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Rock Airplay)»«Adele – When We Were Young (IFPI Finlândia)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Syndicat National de l'Éditon Phonographique)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Magyar Hanglemezkiadók Szövetsége)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Irish Recorded Music Association)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Mexico Airplay)»«Adele – When We Were Young (VG-lista)»«Adele – When We Were Young (NZ Top 40 Singles)»«Adele – When We Were Young (MegaCharts)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Związek Producentów Audio Video)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Portugal Digital Songs)»«Adele – When We Were Young (UK Indie Singles Chart)»«Adele – When We Were Young (UK Singles Chart)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Sverigetopplistan)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Schweizer Hitparade)»«Adele – When We Were Young (Portugal Digital Songs)»«Music Canada – Gold/Platinum – When We Were Young»«NZ Top 40 Singles Chart»«Certified Awards»e